Complaints Policy and Procedures
Introduction and purpose of the policy
The Charity Commission report ‘Cause for Complaint’ published in 2006 states: ‘an effective complaints management system is a proven way of maintaining and building relationships with the people on whom the charity depends.’ Handling complaints well:
- Demonstrates your commitment to your volunteers and other stakeholders.
- Demonstrates your commitment to providing the best possible service.
- Helps you to find out about things that have gone wrong so you can fix them.
- Helps you to prevent things going wrong again in future.
A complaint can be seen as an opportunity to learn and improve for the future, as well as a chance to put things right for the person or organisation that has made the complaint. See Appendix 2 for the definition of a complaint.
The aim of this policy is
- To provide a fair complaints procedure which is clear and easy to use for anyone wishing to make a complaint.
- To publicise the existence of our complaints procedure so that people know how to contact us to make a complaint.
- To make sure everyone knows what to do if a complaint is received.
- To make sure all complaints are investigated fairly and in a timely way.
- To make sure that complaints are, wherever possible, resolved and that relationships are repaired.
- To gather information which helps us to improve what we do.
Eye Matter have an ethos of inclusion, transparency and openness which is communicated to volunteers, staff and Members. All complaints are taken seriously and dealt with in a fair, consistent and confidential manner.
The complaints procedure is communicated to staff and volunteers during induction and through the Safeguarding Policy. If required one-to-one explanations can be provided.
Where Complaints Come From
Complaints may come from anyone who uses our services or works with Eye Matter including staff, other volunteers, members of Eye Matter, partners and visitors, donors, event attendees; indeed any person or organisation who has had some form of interaction with Eye Matter. A complaint can be received verbally, by phone, by email or in writing.
Confidentiality
All complaint information will be handled sensitively, involving only those who need to know and following any relevant data protection requirements.
Responsibility
Overall responsibility for this policy and its implementation lies with Eye Matter’s founder Suzie Simmons. who may, if necessary, also involve any other relevant members of staff, volunteers and members.
How to make a complaint
Complaints must be made in writing and sent to Eye Matter’s Founder.
Receiving Complaints
All written complaints received should be recorded. Where a verbal complaint is received, this should, where possible, be agreed to be an accurate account in writing with the complainant before further action is taken.
The person who receives a complaint should:
- Write down the facts of the complaint, which should include the date, time, location and nature of the complaint as well as the name and details of anyone else involved in the complaint.
- Take the complainant's name and contact details including email address, home address and telephone number.
- Ask what action they think should be taken to encourage resolution.
- Note down the relationship of the complainant to Eye Matter.
- Tell the complainant that we have a complaints procedure.
- Tell the complainant what will happen next and how long it is likely to take.
Resolving Complaints - The Procedure
Stage One
In many cases, a complaint is best resolved by the person responsible for the issue being complained about. If the complaint has been received by that person, they may be able to resolve it swiftly and should do so if possible and appropriate.
Whether or not the complaint has been resolved, the complaint information should be passed to Eye Matter’s Founder within 72 hours so that it can be logged centrally.
On receiving the complaint, Eye Matter’s Founder records it in the complaints book and, If it has not already been resolved, Eye Matter’s Founder may investigate or delegate an appropriate person to investigate further. Where applicable, the person(s) involved in the complaint will be given a copy of the Problem Solving Policy and Procedures.
If the complaint relates to a specific person, they should be informed of the nature of the complaint and given a fair opportunity to respond. Discretion should be exercised in releasing details of the complainant as necessary.
Complaints should be acknowledged by the person handling the complaint within one week. The acknowledgement should say who is dealing with the complaint and when the person complaining can expect a reply.
Ideally complainants should receive a definitive reply within four weeks. If this is not possible because, for example, an investigation has not been fully completed, a progress report should be sent with an indication of when a full reply will be given.
Whether the complaint is justified or not, the reply to the complainant should describe any investigation, conclusions and any action taken as a result.
Stage Two
If the complainant feels that the problem has not been satisfactorily resolved at Stage One, they can request that the complaint is reviewed.
The request for a review should be acknowledged within one week of receiving it. The acknowledgement should say who will deal with the case and when the complainant can expect a reply. The person who dealt with the original complaint at Stage One should be kept informed of what is happening.
Depending on the severity or complexity of the complaint, an Appeals Committee may be convened to investigate the facts of the case themselves or delegate a suitably senior person to do so. This may involve reviewing the nature and findings of the initial investigations of the case and speaking with the person who dealt with the complaint at Stage One.
Ideally complainants should receive a definitive reply within four weeks. If this is not possible because for example, an investigation has not been fully completed or the Appeals Committee do not meet within this timeframe, a progress report should be sent with an indication of when a full reply will be given.
Whether the complaint is upheld or not, the reply to the complainant should describe the action taken to investigate the complaint, conclusions from the investigation and any action taken as a result.
The decision taken at this stage is final, unless the Appeals Committee decides it is appropriate to seek external assistance to obtain a solution.
External Stage
If the complainant wishes they may contact the Charity Commission:
- Charity Commission. Information about the kind of complaints the Commission can involve itself in can be found on their website at: charitycommission.gov.uk/publications/cc47.aspx.
Variation of the Complaints Procedure
Eye Matter’s Founder may vary the procedure for good any reasonable reason; for instance to avoid a conflict of interest.
Monitoring and Learning from Complaints
Complaints should be reviewed annually to identify any trends which may indicate a need to take further action.
Appendix 1 Practical Guidance for Handling Verbal Complaints
- Remain calm and respectful throughout the conversation.
- Listen - allow the person to talk about the complaint in their own words. Sometimes a person just wants to ‘let off steam’.
- Don't debate the facts in the first instance, especially if the person is angry.
- Show an interest in what is being said but refrain from personal opinion / agreement / disagreement.
- Ask for clarification wherever necessary.
- Show that you have understood the complaint by reflecting back what you have noted down.
- Acknowledge the person's feelings (even if you feel that they are being unreasonable) - you can do this without making a comment on the complaint itself or making any admission of fault on behalf of the organisation, e.g. "I understand that this situation is frustrating for you".
- If you feel that an apology is deserved for something that was the responsibility of your organisation, then apologise.
- Ask the person what they would like done to resolve the issue.
- Be clear about what you can do, how long it will take and what it will involve.
- Do not promise things you or the organisation cannot deliver.
- Give clear and valid reasons why requests cannot be met.
- Make sure that the person understands what they have been told.
- If appropriate, inform the person about the available avenues of review or appeal.
Appendix 2 Definitions
Definition of a Complaint for the purposes of this policy
A complaint is any expression of dissatisfaction, about any aspect of Eye Matter and which includes at least one person, or an aspect of volunteering, work or service made by a person outside Eye Matter about the behaviour of the organisation, or an individual from Eye Matter.
An expression of dissatisfaction made by a staff member or volunteer(including members) about the behaviour of the organisation, or an individual staff member or volunteer, is called a grievance. A grievance is an issue, complaint, dispute, concern or problem, which does not involve alleged serious misconduct. This is the focus of the Grievance Policy and Procedures for Volunteers and staff.
Allegations of serious misconduct or behaviour and performance related issues should be resolved by reference to Eye Matter’s Founder or a member of the Trustees.
Where a staff member or volunteer has serious concerns about the illegal or abusive conduct of the organisation or an individual staff member or volunteer within it, but is unable to use the grievance procedure because the person they should report to is implicated in the malpractice, then they have recourse to the Whistleblowing Policy.